Trying CIA kidnappers and torturers in absentia

This is from Hornberger's Blog. As this article notes the U.S. somehow considers the CIA above the law. If any other agency did this there would be hell to pay. Italy is no doubt quite angry that the CIA actions simply ruined their own investigations--although some think that at least some in the Italian govt. were aware what was happening. Note that some who belonged to Italy's military intelligence service are actually on trial. Of course the U.S. government has refused to co-operate even though Italy is a staunch ally of the U.S.


Hornberger’s Blog
Wednesday, April 16, 2008


Trying CIA Kidnappers and Torturers in Absentia
by Jacob G. Hornberger

Twenty-six CIA agents are scheduled to go on trial today for kidnapping. Unfortunately, all of them will be tried in absentia because the Bush administration, which has long claimed to be against torture, refuses to send the accused kidnappers to Italy, where the prosecution is taking place.

The Italian indictment alleges that in June 2005 the CIA officials kidnapped Hassan Osama Nasr, who is known as Abu Omar, in Italy and then forcibly carried him against his will to Egypt for torture. Nasr claims that Egyptian torturers then tortured him brutally.

The Italian torture trial also involves nine Italian defendants who allegedly conspired with the CIA agents to kidnap Omar and rendition him to Egypt. They include Gen. Nicolo Pollari, the former head of SISMI, Italy’s military intelligence service, who was forced to resign over the Omar kidnapping, as well as his former deputy, Marco Mancini.

Hopefully, the trial will shed more light on the CIA’s kidnapping, rendition, and torture scheme. As Joanne Mariner, terrorism and counterterrorism director at Human Rights Watch (who will be speaking at The Future of Freedom Foundation’s upcoming June 6-8 conference “Restoring The Republic 2008: Foreign Policy and Civil Liberties”), stated in a Reuters news dispatch: “It should show the world that Italy does not give get-out-of-jail-free cards to kidnappers. The CIA’s rendition program should be on trial in the United States. But since the US Department of Justice has utterly failed in its responsibility to investigate and prosecute these serious crimes, it is up to Italy to bring the perpetrators to justice.”

To date, neither Congress nor the Justice Department has shown any interest in conducting a serious investigation into any criminal wrongdoing by the CIA, including its kidnapping, secret prisons, rendition, and torture schemes. That’s because in the minds of U.S. officials nothing that the CIA does can ever be considered criminal, especially since here in the United States the CIA is not just above the law, it is the law. Fortunately, Italian prosecutors feel differently.

Jacob Hornberger is founder and president of The Future of Freedom Foundation. Send him email.